Firefox, Brave and Vivaldi share less data than Edge
Researchers checked for the Dutch government what browsers send back to their makers. Edge kept sending data to Microsoft, even with the settings Microsoft itself recommends.
What happened
What does a browser send back to its maker while you are simply getting on with your work? Researchers found out for the Dutch government, and Microsoft’s browser came off worst.
On 28 October the Dutch Ministry of Justice and Security published the study. It was commissioned by SLM Cloud, the team within that ministry that negotiates government-wide agreements with Microsoft, Google, Amazon and European cloud providers. Security.NL named SLM Cloud and Dutch IT Channel named the ministry, so both were right. The consultancy Privacy Company did the work. It compared Edge for Business, the business version of Edge, with the business version of Firefox, with Brave and with Norway’s Vivaldi. The reason: Microsoft offers no browser that falls under the government’s terms for personal data, and will not reconsider. It did recommend settings that were supposed to send less data.
With exactly those settings, Edge kept sending telemetry to Microsoft, data about how the browser is used, and traffic kept going to Bing. Switching to another search engine through central management did not work. Microsoft sites such as MSN, Bing and Office set tracking cookies despite the strictest tracking protection. And SmartScreen, the filter meant to protect against dangerous websites, did not work during the tests. So Edge collected more personal data than the other three.
Set up properly, those three sent little more than the IP address when fetching updates. Vivaldi is the only one that sends nothing to the United States. But Vivaldi allows tracking cookies by default, and its DirectMatch feature steers search terms and bookmarks towards paying sponsors. On 28 October Vivaldi said administrators can switch DirectMatch off centrally from version 8.2; that has not been tested yet.
SLM Cloud advises the organisations that supply workstations to ministries to look into whether Firefox Enterprise can replace Edge in the short term. Brave and Vivaldi may cause problems with other software on the workstation. Later, with a ‘sovereign workplace’ in mind, it advises looking at Vivaldi and other browsers too. It is advice to investigate, not a decision.
From a privacy perspective, Mozilla Firefox Enterprise is preferable to Microsoft Edge for Business.
From SLM Cloud’s memo of 12 October 2026, translated
The background
What a browser sends home
Every browser talks to its maker: to fetch updates or refresh a list of dangerous sites. Telemetry goes further. It is data about how you use the software, often with a number that makes your device recognisable; Microsoft itself writes that Edge sends it with an identifier unique to your device. The researchers had switched Edge’s telemetry off, and still saw 13 requests carrying telemetry go to Microsoft.
Who decides about the data matters too. A processor may only use data as the customer instructs; a controller decides for itself. For Edge, Microsoft is the latter, and its general privacy statement lists 18 purposes, plus room for purposes it considers compatible with them. That is not unusual: at the time of the study, none of the other makers would act as a processor either. Mozilla did say this may change with the new Firefox Enterprise.
The government has been watching for years
Back in 2018 the Dutch government had Privacy Company examine what Office sent to Microsoft, for some 300,000 government workstations. Office turned out to send 23,000 to 25,000 types of events to Microsoft, and the researchers found eight high risks. Microsoft then promised settings to limit that flow and a tool to view the data. Microsoft 365 Copilot followed, among others, and in 2025 the cloud services of Microsoft, Google and Amazon were next in line.
Edge had been on the list for a while. Microsoft gave advice on privacy-friendly settings in 2024, and in August 2025 Dutch IT Channel reported that the government would compare Edge with Firefox, because the browser falls outside its contracts.
Firefox on the rise
In mid-October Mozilla launched Firefox Enterprise: the browser plus a management console that organisations run on their own servers. Sales start in France, Germany, Austria and Switzerland. According to Mozilla’s own figures, more than 213.5 million people now use Firefox, the highest number in three years. The Netherlands has 2.6 million active installations, a level last seen at the end of 2022.
Our analysis
A setting is a promise; only measuring shows whether it holds
The most striking thing about this study is not that Edge collects more than Firefox. It is that Microsoft’s own recommended settings did not do what they promised: telemetry off did not mean telemetry off, and choosing another search engine did not stop Bing. None of this showed in the settings screen; it only came out when the researchers looked at the network traffic, just as with Office in 2018.
What the coverage leaves out: the alternatives are not spotless either. Brave and Vivaldi take extensions from Google’s store, and a visit there leaves three persistent Google cookies behind. Vivaldi earns money from sponsored suggestions. And the Edge that was tested dates from November 2025; Microsoft may have changed things since. The heart of the matter is the contract. As long as the maker decides for itself what to do with your data, settings only go so far.
Our expectation: Microsoft will fix the settings that do not work, but keep its role as the one who decides about the data, as it has already signalled. For any organisation the lesson is the same: for every tool, ask not only what the settings promise, but what actually leaves the building and who decides about it.
What stands out
- Bing stayed the search engine The central policy to make DuckDuckGo or Startpage the default did not work in Edge.
- The safety filter stayed silent On known dangerous sites, Edge sent not a single request to SmartScreen. The researchers do not know whether another setting blocked it.
- A regulator turned into a hotel Typing the name of data protection commissioner Marit Hansen into Vivaldi brought up a sponsored suggestion for a Marriott hotel.
- Access only with an account Privacy Company asked Microsoft what data it held on the test user. Microsoft handed over nothing without a Microsoft account, even though the test deliberately used none.
What it means for you
Every tool on your laptops sends something back to its maker. What that is, the settings screen will not tell you.
- Check what actually leaves the building For an important tool, have the network traffic examined, or ask the supplier for an independent assessment. A setting switched to ‘off’ is not proof.
- Ask who decides about the data If the supplier is a processor, it only does what you instruct. If it decides for itself, it can use your data for its own purposes too.
- Manage the browser centrally Fix the settings for every workstation and limit extensions. Whatever your colleagues install themselves can send data to others.
Where we come in · Advisory
We look at what your tools send out
When we work out with you in a Discovery or Roadmap where AI can help your processes, we also look at the tools you already use: which data leaves the building, to whom, and what you can do about it. Independent of any supplier; we don’t sell browsers.
Do you know what your software sends back home?
Tell us which tools you use every day. We’ll think it through with you independently and always reply within one working day.